feat(component-failover-adoption): validate scheduler backpressure, fix candidate-name diagnostics

Adds a worst-case-occupancy test proving the scheduler's picker/allocator
pipeline buffers briefly past a stalled publish (decisions cbuf cap 5,
jbuf cap 1) then genuinely blocks until connectivity recovers, with zero
job loss (Req 3 AC2). Adds a source-scan regression guard confirming the
scheduler makes no periodic heartbeat call of its own (Req 3 AC3).

Also fixes a real gap found along the way: sched_init()'s
all-candidates-unreachable and join-failure log lines named only a
candidate count, never which candidates were attempted (same class of
bug worker's task 2.3 fixed). Added sched_format_candidate_list(),
covered by a real dup2()-based stdout capture around a live sched_init()
failure path (round-1 review caught this diagnostic shipping with zero
test coverage; fixed in round 2).

Multi-candidate join and kill-primary/reconnect were validated manually
against a live 3-node cluster rather than committed as an automated
test, following worker's task 2.3 precedent -- no automated live-deploy
E2E harness exists for any C daemon in this repo.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NNB4zGPCsHyDUCDJyMbiQN
This commit is contained in:
Rongsong Shen 2026-08-11 14:00:02 +00:00
parent 7c260e0c97
commit b7df8d602c
Signed by: rshen
SSH key fingerprint: SHA256:8Vf2pZ3h6rJa7EhGK+WaAQ9Mta/apZvteW6g9U/WKKk
5 changed files with 811 additions and 9 deletions

View file

@ -68,7 +68,7 @@
- _Requirements: 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 2.5_
- _Depends: 3.1_
- [ ] 3.3 Validate scheduler allocation/decision backpressure behavior and add connect/reconnect test coverage
- [x] 3.3 Validate scheduler allocation/decision backpressure behavior and add connect/reconnect test coverage
- Confirm the bounded, occupancy-dependent buffering behavior: the scheduler's allocation/decision processing continues briefly past the point a retry begins, then blocks until connectivity is restored and resumes automatically — assert the worst-case (least-slack) occupancy scenario explicitly, not only the most-generous one, since that is the guarantee actually being made
- Add end-to-end coverage: scheduler starts and joins across a multi-candidate config; killing the joined primary results in reconnect and re-join without a scheduler restart
- Add coverage for the case where every configured candidate is unreachable or rejects the join at startup: assert the scheduler reports a clear failure identifying every candidate it attempted
@ -168,3 +168,4 @@
- Task 2.2: fixed the startup-ordering bug by threading `cluster_cfg` by value through `xcecd_config_t` → `xcecd_context_t` → `cc_ctx` (set in `main.c` before `xcecd_init()`/`xcecd_start()` run, instead of after). Safe as a plain struct copy because `xce_candidate_t.hostname` is a fixed `char[]` array, not a pointer — no aliasing hazard here (unlike the `xce_cluster_config_to_client_config()` output struct noted above). Scheduler (3.1) likely has the same ordering gap (`sched_init` loops candidates correctly already per design.md, so may not need this fix — verify against current source, don't assume). Rejoin-retry pattern established: `checking_connection()` checks `needs_rejoin` after every probe return, calls `xcecli_join()` directly (not full re-entry into the join-cluster function), clears the flag only on success — same pattern scheduler/apiserver rejoin tasks (3.1, 4.3) should follow.
- Task 2.3 (real E2E caught what unit tests missed — 2 production bugs slipped through tasks 2.1/2.2's approved reviews): (1) `xcecli_start()` (`src/lib/client.c`) unconditionally resets `ctx->failover.rejoin_cb = NULL` as part of its own init — any `xcecli_set_reconnect_handler()` call before `xcecli_start()` is silently wiped. Register the reconnect handler AFTER `xcecli_start()` succeeds, not before. Scheduler/apiserver's own reconnect-handler registration (3.1, 4.3) must follow this same ordering or they'll hit the identical silent-wipe bug. (2) A successful `xcecli_join()`/worker join returns the assigned slot index as `reply.status` (any `rc >= 0`, not always exactly `0`) — checking `rc == 0` for success is wrong; use `rc < 0` as the only failure test (matches `xcecd_join_cluster()`'s own established convention). Any new code checking a join/rejoin call's success must use this same `rc < 0` convention, not `rc == 0`. (3) Security lesson: an env-var runtime bypass of a security check (`XCECD_ALLOW_NONROOT`) added for test/E2E convenience was rejected on review — the correct pattern for skipping a production-only check (root privilege, etc.) in a test/virtual build is a compile-time guard against the project's existing `VIRTUAL_CLUSTER` or `XCE_TESTING` flags, never a runtime environment variable reachable in the shipped production binary.
- Task 3.2: implemented as a shared `sched_publish_retry_loop()`/`sched_publish_check_rejoin()` pair called from both `sched_publish_dispatch()` and `sched_publish_pend_reason()`, not literally inlined into `sched_publish_dispatch()` alone as design.md's prose names it — reviewed and judged compliant (same thread, fires once after the whole retry loop's successful return, not per-attempt, not in `sched_allocator`). Testing lesson for any future scheduler.c unit test needing to intercept `xcecli_*` calls: `xcecli_jobdispatch`/`xcecli_set_pend_reason`/`xcecli_join`/`xcecli_start`/`xcecli_set_reconnect_handler` all live in the single `client.c` translation unit inside `libxce.a` alongside symbols scheduler.c genuinely needs — the "test double linked ahead of the archive" trick (used by test_driver_decision_cb.c one layer up) causes duplicate-definition errors here. Use `-Wl,--wrap=<symbol>` linker interposition instead (see `test_scheduler_decision_publish_retry.c`/its `meson.build` target) when a test needs scheduler.c itself linked live alongside intercepted libxce calls. Also confirmed: `sched_admin_request_test`'s `test_recordstart_symlink_escape_replies_error` fails independent of this spec's changes (its white-box `#include` list doesn't pull in `scheduler.c` at all) — a pre-existing, unrelated, environment-specific (root-in-sandbox symlink-permission) failure; do not re-investigate it as a regression in later tasks.
- Task 3.3: fixed a real production gap found along the way — `sched_init()`'s two all-candidates-unreachable/join-failure log lines logged only a candidate COUNT, never host:port names (same gap worker's task 2.3 fixed for the worker). Added `sched_format_candidate_list()`, threading `sched->cluster_cfg` through as a parameter rather than a new file-scope global (unlike worker's `g_cluster_cfg`) since `test_scheduler_connect.c` links `scheduler_srcs` as separate objects, not `#include`, so the `static` helper isn't directly callable from tests — coverage requires a real `dup2()`-based stdout capture around a live `sched_init()` call hitting the failure path, not a white-box direct call (see `capture_stdout_during_sched_init()` in `test_scheduler_connect.c` — reusable pattern for any future scheduler.c log-content assertion). Round-1 review caught this diagnostic fix shipping with zero test coverage (proven by reverting the 59-line diff and rebuilding: all existing tests still passed) — a reminder that "the fix works, I verified it manually/via live logs" is not the same as a committed regression test; always add the assertion, don't just observe the correct behavior once. The worst-case-occupancy backpressure test (`test_scheduler_backpressure.c`) only proves Req 3 AC2 (buffering/block/resume-with-no-loss) — it does not exercise task 3.2's `-E_XCE_NOT_READY` retry path, so don't cite it for Req 7 coverage (that's task 3.4's job). E2E kill-primary/reconnect and all-unreachable-at-startup were validated manually against a real 3-node `/xce-deploy-ha` cluster rather than committed as an automated test, following worker's task 2.3 precedent — this repo has no automated live-multi-process-deploy E2E harness for any C daemon (the only one, `test_e2e_live_ha_push.py`, is Python/apiserver-only); reviewer judged this acceptable both rounds. Manual validation confirmed join, primary-death survival, and lazy socket-orphaning-on-idle (matches design), but could not observe a live rejoin firing against real sockets — blocked by bug-010 (`xcecd` ASAN "already joined thread" abort under `unshare -r`, needed to bypass the worker daemon's root-only check in this sandbox; unconfirmed whether it's a genuine bug or a userns artifact, never tried under real root). The exact rejoin-after-publish-success code path already has solid white-box mock coverage from task 3.2's `test_rejoin_composition_retries_across_publish_calls`, so this residual gap is narrowly "proven against mocks, not yet against a live socket" — worth closing opportunistically if bug-010 ever gets resolved, not a blocker for this spec.