xceadmin's --controller option (config push, and scheduler record
start/stop/status) accepted only a single host:port. Passing every
configured controller as a comma-separated list -- the natural way to
query an HA cluster without knowing which node is alive/primary --
mis-parsed the whole joined string as one bogus hostname and failed
with a DNS-resolution error.
Adds xceadmin.discovery.resolve_controllers() (comma-split candidate
parsing) and follow_redirects_any() (tries each candidate in order,
skipping ones that are unreachable at the network level -- connection
refused, DNS failure, or a discovery timeout -- mirroring xcecli/
xce_test's own client-side master-rotation failover). A candidate that
IS reachable but returns a genuine protocol-level failure is not
retried against a different node. push.py and scheduler.py's own
duplicated single-host _split_controller helpers are removed in favor
of this shared implementation.
Also fixes a related gap bug-1821's own live verification surfaced:
right after a primary is killed, a standby doesn't start a new
election until its own heartbeat timeout elapses (~10s), so it keeps
redirecting every candidate to the now-dead old primary -- exhausting
the whole candidate list and raising NoPrimaryError, which
_send_admin_request()'s existing transient-retry loop (bug-1713/1715)
never caught. That loop now retries on NoPrimaryError too, using its
own (longer) budget sized for the heartbeat-timeout-plus-election
window rather than the RPC-level "already electing" budget the
original retry logic was tuned for.
TDD RED->GREEN, 304/304 tests passing. Live-verified end to end: a
comma-list correctly skips a dead first candidate and reaches a live
one on a healthy cluster, and correctly rides out a real primary kill
and re-election (retry loop visibly cycling ~15s) to reach the newly-
elected primary rather than failing immediately.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01RLSNJhNoULvVcUhXEFafQC
- probe_config() now wraps probe in Request envelope matching push_config()
- Controller OPCode_probeConfigTag handler replies through xce_reply()
with redirectHost/redirectPort populated
- follow_redirects works identically for both push and probe flows
config push crashed on every real controller with a capnp KjException --
xce_reply() wraps every reply in an outer Request{body.replymsg} envelope,
but discovery.py/push.py decoded raw wire bytes directly as a bare
RequestReply. Adds a shared decode_reply() unwrap point used by both call
sites, and fixes the same wrong-shape assumption baked into task 5.6's
and test_cli.py's mock-server fixtures.
deploy-ha.sh no longer takes a <data-dir> argument or --build-config
flag. Every deploy now generates a fresh self-signed TLS cert/key
(openssl, RSA 2048, 10y validity) directly into the deploy dir's
certs/, and builds cluster.bin directly into controller/ctrl-1/conf/
via xceadmin -- no intermediate staging directory, nothing preserved
across runs. run-ha-soak.sh (/xce-test-ha) updated to match: dropped
its own XCE_HA_DATADIR-based precondition entirely. Updated 4 callers
(run-ha-soak.sh, test-heartbeat-tolerance.sh, test-commit-durability.sh,
both xce-deploy-ha/xce-test-ha SKILL.md docs).
Separately: xcecommon.wire.connect() was loading a client-side TLS
cert, diverging from the real reference client -- netio.c's
create_ssl_context() presents no certificate at all when acting as a
client (cert_file/key_file both NULL, bare TLS_client_method()).
Fixed connect() to match, and since nothing else consumed cert_dir
(verify_mode=CERT_NONE throughout, no CA check either), removed it
end-to-end: discovery.follow_redirects(), push.push_config()/
probe_config(), and the --cert-dir CLI flag.
Server-side cert loading (mock TLS test servers) is unaffected --
moved into a shared session-scoped tls_certs fixture (new
tests/conftest.py, openssl-generated) replacing 3 duplicated
REPO_HA_DATA_DIR/skipif blocks. Net result: those tests no longer skip
under a hermetic nix build sandbox (which never had ha/data/) --
verified 165/165 passed, 0 skipped, via both meson compile and a full
nix build --option sandbox false .#xcecore_debug rebuild (previously
128 passed / 37 skipped there).
ha/data/{xce.crt,xce.key} removed from git tracking. Requirements
2.3/2.4 and 8.3/8.4/8.5 marked superseded in requirements.md with
dated correction notes.
Adds end-to-end propagation tests through push_config's real
composition with xceadmin.discovery (not just discovery.py's own
unit tests): a 4-mock-server redirect chain proving TooManyRedirectsError
surfaces correctly, and a monkeypatched-timeout test proving
NoPrimaryError does too, without waiting out a real 30s socket
timeout. Also locks in and documents a real wire-contract limitation:
ProbeConfigTagReply carries no rejection signal, so dry-run's
accepted=False path is unreachable today by design, not an oversight.
This completes all 18 sub-tasks in tasks.md.
push_config()/probe_config(): build/send Request{opcode:upgradeConfig}
and the direct-struct ProbeConfigTagRequest respectively, following
redirects to the primary for the former (ProbeConfigTagReply has no
redirect fields, so probe_config connects directly). Maps controller
status/reply-variant failures to typed results/errors. Tested against
a real local TLS mock controller built from the bundled schema, since
neither opcode has a live controller-side handler today (separately
documented, unrelated to this task).
Unblocked mid-task by bug-1461 (commit e53c086): controller.capnp had
a struct-name collision that miscompiled UpgradeConfigRequest.sha256/
.bytes, making this task's core request impossible to construct via
pycapnp until fixed at the schema root.
